Children literature is the way to “mold” children’s characteristics. It tells them what behaviors are accepted and how to be kind to others. In addition, fairy tales or folktales demonstrate some moral lessons. They are not simply a story for young people but also a medium carrying messages for everyone.
The comparison between Charlie Perrault and Grimm brothers shows that the writing styles corresponds to their education, living condition, generation they were born in, etc. To begin with, Perrault was born in a middle-class family, working as a lawyer just the same job as his dad did. Without any doubt, he was quite rich and enjoyed relatively higher status during his life. That’s why his writing is full with descriptions of fine clothes, delicate furniture, and luxurious decorations. Besides, his occupation probably leads to his serious writing style compared to Grimm brothers, being meticulous about the detail and logic.
When it comes to Grimm brothers, they were scholars first and children literature writers second. Since they had been immersed in language related world, they were good at visualize the scene, characters, and making the plot more vivid. Plus, they focus more on rhyme of words. Through Cinderella, readers can find that the birds sending fine clothes read a short rhyme. Therefore, their story would be relatively interesting and tend to intrigue imaginations, which made it more appropriate for children to read. Aside from writing style, they show their considerations for poor people from the story.
As for which story I like, I would say that I love Perrault’s Cinderella and Grimm Brothers’ Little Red Cap. First, Perrault’s Cinderella is more independent and optimistic. Through conversation between her and her step-sisters, I consider that Cinderella is humble. She doesn’t blame anyone for her fate, and detest her family, at least not shown in the story. On the flip side, she is not so sorrowful. In Grimms’ version, Cinderella cries a lot, which is the part I don’t like the most. She is too weak and vulnerable. Also, the end of the story shows several bloody scenes which involves with violent and cruelty.
No comments:
Post a Comment